تفاصيل البحث
Biosafty of Ziziphus Lotus Extract as Hair and Body Wash: Animal Study
ورقة منشورة
5/5/2013 12:00:00 AM
كرسي المعلم محمد بن لادن لأبحاث الإعجاز العلمي في الطب النبوي
Archives Des Sciences Vol 66, No. 5;May 2013
686 ISSN 1661-464X
Biosafty of Ziziphus Lotus Extract as Hair and Body Wash:
Animal Study
Bassem Y. Sheikh1,2 and Wael M. Elsaed1,3,4
1MABL Chair for Scientific Miracles of Prophetic Medicine.
2Depatement of Surgery and 3 Department of Anatomy, Faculty of Medicine, Taibah University, Kingdom
of Saudi Arab.
4 Department of Anatomy, Faculty of Medicine, Mansoura University, Egypt.
*Corresponding Author
Prof. Bassem Yousef Sheikh, MD, FRCS, FICS
Professor of Vascular Endovascular Neurosurgery
Director, Al-Moalim MA Bin Ladin (MABL) chair for Scientific Miracles of Prophetic Medicine,
Faculty of Medicine, Taibah University
P.O. Box: 30001, Al-Madinah Al-Nabawiah, Saudi Arabia
E-mail: askdrsheikh@gmail.com
Archives Des Sciences Vol 66, No. 5;May 2013
687 ISSN 1661-464X
Background:
Zizphus lotus (Sidr) tree is commonly used in traditional medicine for treatment of multiple
diseases particularly of skin. Its extract is rich in beneficial chemicals that help wound healing and
treatment of boils and fruncles. The emollient properties of the extract are thought to be valuable as a hair
and body wash in prolonged use.
Materials and methods:
Water extract from the green leaves of the plant was prepared in two concentrations (50% and
100%). The extract was added to the commercial base of shampoo. The produced wash was applied to the
skin of rabbits. 12 rabbits were used. They were divided into 3 groups. Group I served as the control. Group
II subjected to 50% of the wash and group III to 100%. The wash was applied for 30 consecutive days then
skin samples were collected after animal scarification and examined histologically.
Results:
Safety of 50% concentration of sidr wash was proofed. It induced no signs of allergy or
inflammation. No change in epidermal thickness or inflammatory cell infiltration was noted in comparison
to the controls. However 100% concentration induced epidermal thickness and inflammatory cell
infiltration of the dermis. Small areas of focal hemorrhage occurred in dermis.
Conclusion:
Ziziphus extract is a promising material to formulate a new hair and body wash (Shampoo). Our
results showed that 50% conc. hair and body wash is save for utilization.
Key wards:
Ziziphus lotus extract, Skin, Hair follicles, Prophetic medicine, Complementary, Alternative,
Scientific chair.
Archives Des Sciences Vol 66, No. 5;May 2013
688 ISSN 1661-464X
Introduction
Ziziphus lotus is a tropical evergreen tree with shiny green leaves. It can reach a height of 2-5
metres (6.6–16 ft). It is abundantly present in the Mediterranean region, throughout Libya to Morocco,
Algeria and southern European countries like Spain, Sicily, Greece and Cyprus (Pottier Alapetite,
1981).The edible fruit is a globose dark yellow drupe 1–1.5 cm diameter called a nabk. Its common Arabic
name is sidr (Dafni et al. ,2005).
The plant extract has been studied (Ikram et al.,1976 and Aynehchi and Mahoodian, 1973) and
its chemical composition is well-known (Younes et al., 1996 and Mahran et al., 1996). The main
constituents of the essential oil are alpha-terpineol (16.4%) and linalool (11.5%);of the hydrocarbons are
n-pentacosane forms (81%); of methyl esters include methyl palmitate, methyl stearate and methyl
myristate; of aglycones are beta-Sitosterol, oleanolic acid and maslinic acid; of alkaloids include:
zizyphine-F, jubanine-A and amphibine-H. The plant leaves also contains saponin glycosides (Mahran et
al., 1996; Abdel-Galil and El-Jissry., 1991).
Extracts from different parts of the tree is commonly used in traditional and ancestral medicine for
treatment of several pathologies including digestive disorders, weakness, liver complaints, obesity, urinary
troubles, diabetes, skin infections, fever, diarrhoea and insomnia (Lahlou et al., 2002). Also it has sedative,
antidiabetic and hypoglycaemic effects (Tschesche and Kaubmann, 1975, Anand et al., 1989 and
Zakaria et. al., 1999). In Saudi Arabia it is used for the treatment of ulcers, wounds, eye diseases and
bronchitis (Adzu et. al., 2001). The leaves of this plant have been used for washing the hair and body and
for healing skin diseases such as atopic dermatitis (Amin, 1991 and Nafisy, 1989).
The medicinal properties of this plant depend on the part of the plant concerned (root, leaf stalk
and pulp or fruit) and the extract used (ethanolic, butanolic etc.). Anti-inflammatory, analgesic and
anti-ulcerogenic activities of Zizyphus lotus have been demonstrated in rodents (Borgi et al. 2007 and
Borgi et al. 2008).
The 10% methanol extract of the stem bark of the plant showed antidiarrheal effects (Adzu et. al.,
2003). Different extracts and fractions of the leaves, fruits and seeds of Ziziphus showed antiviral,
antifungal and antibacterial activities (Shaht et. al., 2001). The aqueous extract of the plant is reported to
Archives Des Sciences Vol 66, No. 5;May 2013
689 ISSN 1661-464X
possess antinociceptive activity (Adzu et. al., 2001). It also has strong mollusuicidal activity (Lahlou et.
al., 2002).
The plant extract containing cyclopeptides and peptide alkaloids form was found to induce
sedative activity (Hwang et. al., 2001).
Fruit has been used for its emollient properties, and a mixture of dried leaves and fruits is applied
topically in the treatment of boils (Le Floc’h, 1983 and Benammar et al. 2010). It was also proofed to
have antibacterial and antifungal properties (Pandey and Devi, 1990).
Benammar et al. 2010 reported a high concentration of vitamin A and C. They also proofed a
notifiable, antioxidant and immunosuppressive activities of the extract.
Anti-inflammatory, analgesic and anti-spasmodic activities of this plant were demonstrated in
rodents (Borgi et al., 2008 and Borgi and Chouchane, 2009).
The Quran mentioned the tree twice (LIII: 13–18; LVI: 28– 32) and it is highly respected by the
Muslims throughout the world (Farooqi, 1997).
The use of the leaves extract on skin is limited to wound healing, boils and furuncles treatment. No
studies on prolonged use of the extract on healthy skin are available. The variable uses and benefits of
extract uses made us think that the use of the leaves extract as hair and body wash will have good results on
skin.
The aim of this study is to investigate the effect of ziziphus lotus extract on healthy skin and hair
of rabbits as preliminary step to use it as a regular human shampoo specified for scalp hair common
problems as hair dandruff, greasy hair or scalp infections as boils or frunclosis.
Material and methods
Plant material:
The leaves of Ziziphus lotus were collected from the trees in Almadinah Alnbawiah locality. Only
green apparent healthy leaves were selected for the study.
Preparation of the leaves extract:
The authenticated leaves were shade dried at room temperature until total dehydration. Dried
aerial parts of plants were blended into fine powder and stored in the dark at a dry place. The powdered
Archives Des Sciences Vol 66, No. 5;May 2013
690 ISSN 1661-464X
aerial part of plants were extracted in a 1/10 (w/v) of water for 12 h under a continuous reflux set-up in a
Soxhlet extractor (hot) or at room temperature (cold) for 24 h (Bouaziz et al. 2009). The extracts were
concentrated by rotary evaporation (Büchi Rotavapor and Büchi Laboratories, Switzerland) at 40°C
under vacuum to dryness and the yield of extraction was determined. All the dried extracts were preserved
in the refrigerator until further use. Plant extracts were dissolved in water (20/80, v/v) at 50 mg/ml before
use (Kokate at al., 2003).
Two concentrations of the extract were prepared. Concentration 1: 50% and 2: 100%. They were
added to a commercial base of shampoo to form two models of the Sidr hair and body wash.
Animals:
Twelve (12) rabbits were used in this experiment. These were divided into three groups I, II, III.
Each group included 4 rabbits.
A skin area of 4 cm- 5cm of back of all animals was marked by a permanent ink pen. Group I
served as control and had application of 3 ml. of water daily with a soft brush for 30 days.
Rabbits of group II were applied with 3 ml. of Sidr hair and body wash (Conc. 1) on the marked
area of skin for 30 days daily with a soft brush. In group III same procedure was used with 3 ml. of the hair
and body wash (Conc. 2). After wash application, the test area was covered with a non-occlusive dressing
(a gauze patch) and then a semi-occlusive bandage for 24 hours and then washed thoroughly with tape
water before next application. The process in then repeated daily for 30 days. At the end of the exposure
period, any residual test substance was removed by distilled water, and carefully dried (fig. 1 a and b).
Animals were observed for signs of inflammation and toxicity once daily. At the end of the
experiment, animals were sacrificed. The tissue samples from skin of the application area were fixed in
neutral buffered formalin solution and latter processed for section cutting at five micron sections. These
were stained with Heamatoxylene and Eosin (Hx & E) and Periodic Acid Schiff (PAS). Histological
examination of the skin of the tested area was compared to the control.
Archives Des Sciences Vol 66, No. 5;May 2013
691 ISSN 1661-464X
Fig. 1 a: Ziziphus hair and body wash applied to skin on the back of the animal after skin shaving
at 4 cm- 5cm area of skin. b: After application of the test substance, the test area were covered with a
non-occlusive dressing (a gauze patch) and then a semi-occlusive bandage for 24 hours.
Results:
At the of the examination period, animals of group II (50% Ziziphus extract conc.) showed no
signs of allergy or discomfort as compared to the controls. Naked eye examination of the tested area of skin
did not show any signs of inflammation (redness or oedema).
Histological examination of the skin sections of group I (the control group) showed the normal
histological features of skin. It was seen to be formed of epidermis with its stratified keratinized squamous
epithelium. Below lays the dermis which is rich in collagenous and elastic fibers. It contains blood vessels
and hair follicles (Fig2 a &b).
Fig. 2 a: Normal skin stained with Hx & E. the epidermis is thin. Dermis is rich in blood vessels and hair
follicles. b: Normal skin stained with PAS. The epidermis is thin and rich in bluish stained keratine scales.
a b
a b
Archives Des Sciences Vol 66, No. 5;May 2013
692 ISSN 1661-464X
The abundant hair follicles in rabbit skin appeared in cross sections formed of external root sheath,
internal root sheath and cortex. The hair itself is seen formed of medulla, cortex and cuticle of the hair (Fig.
3 a &b).
Fig. 3 a: Hair follicle of normal rabbit skin stained with Hx & E. it is formed of external and
internal root sheathes and cortex. b: PAS stained sections showed longitudinally lied hairs formed of
Keratin filaments.
Histological examination of the skin sections of group II showed almost the same histological
features of the control group. Epidermis is of the same thickness. No congestion of the dermal blood vessels
was observed. None of the inflammatory cells was seen invading the dermal tissue (Fig. 4 a &b).
Fig. 4 a: Group II skin section stained with Hx& E showing almost normal skin. b: PAS stained section
showing normal dermis with normal hair follicle.
b a
b a
Archives Des Sciences Vol 66, No. 5;May 2013
693 ISSN 1661-464X
In contrast, group III (50% Ziziphus extract conc.) showed signs of inflammation of the skin in the
form of epidermal thickness, congestion of the dermal blood vessels with extravasations of the red blood
cells. Inflammatory cells (plasma cells and esinophils) are seen invading the tissues around the blood
vessels (Fig. 5 a, b & c). Higher magnifications showed thickness of the external root sheath of the hair
follicle. Hair shafts showed no changes compared to the controls (Fig6 a & b).
Fig. 5 a: Hx& E skin section of group III showing thickened epidermis and congestion of the
dermal blood vessels. b: PAS stained section at higher magnification showing small areas of hemorrhage in
the dermis. C: PAS stained section shows inflammatory cells invading the nearby area close to the blood
vessels.
a b
c c
Archives Des Sciences Vol 66, No. 5;May 2013
694 ISSN 1661-464X
Fig.6 a: Hx & E stained section of group III shows hair follicles with thickened external root
sheath compared to the control group. b: PAS higher magnification no changes in the hair shaft compared to
the other groups.
Discussion:
Corneal layer thickness is one of the measures to assess the efficiency of body washes and shampoos
(Groux and Bensignor, 2000). Our experiment showed that the 50% conc. of sidr skin and body wash did
not change the thickness of the epidermis as a whole. However higher concentration (100%) increased the
thickness to a notifiable extent (Fig. 6 a & b).
Although the clinical improvement is the main criterion to evaluate the efficacy of shampoos
(Curtis, 1998), the Ziziphus extract at 50 % proved to be safe on the histological level.
Oils in Ziziphus (alpha-terpineol and linalool) are helpful to soften and rehydrate the skin, and
reduce transcutaneous water loss. It also helps softening and moisturizing. Its major effect is probably by
incorporation of essential fatty acids (especially linoleic acid) into stratum corneum ceramides (Campbell
and Kirkwood, 1993).
The hydrocarbon n-pentacosane in Ziziphus extract is believed to be helpful in prevention of skin
diseases as boils and fruncles. Similar studies on the same hydrocarbon extracted from Capparis decidua
edgew (Verma et al., 2011) proofed this effect on skin.
b b a
Archives Des Sciences Vol 66, No. 5;May 2013
695 ISSN 1661-464X
Methyl esters are known to cause skin irritation in high concentration. However its presence in
Ziziphus hair and body wash is believed to be non toxic as its level does not reach the toxic level (Hewitt et
al., 2000).
Aglycones play a preventive role in age-related skin changes accelerated by the menopause
without the harmful oestrogenic side effects on reproductive tissues (Cassidy, 2003). It showed consistent
efficacy in managing conditions of oestrogen deprivation, and its cosmetic creams were actually used to
improve skin dryness and wrinkles (Rona et al., 2004).
As Ziziphus contains saponin glycoside, it has been shown to decrease inflammation and granular
tissue formation in rats (Patel et al. 2011).
Our results add to the fact that the plant in its raw form is already used in many parts of the world
for the care of the skin (Abbiw, 1990). The chemical composition and phytochemicals present in the plant
caused the cultural spread and wide uses particularly in soothing hair and skin (adsu et al., 2001).
Recommendation:
From our results, Ziziphus extract is a promising material to formulate a new hair and body wash
(Shampoo). Our results showed that 50% conc. hair and body wash is save for utilization. The proposed
shampoo must be left on skin and hair for several minutes, to allow the active ingredients to be properly
absorbed and reach adequate levels in the deep cellular layers. This length of time should be not less than 5
minutes. The skin should then be rinsed thoroughly, for at least 5 minutes, to prevent irritation and to enable
the skin to become adequately hydrated. The proposed shampoo may be applied several times a week.
Acknowledgment:
The authors would like to express the gratitude for the MABL chairn for their financial support (Grant
No. SMPM1434/A0106) and to Mr. Hany Salah and Mr. Mohamed Abdulsamad for their clerkal work.
Archives Des Sciences Vol 66, No. 5;May 2013
696 ISSN 1661-464X
References:
1. Abbiw D.K. (1990) Useful plants of Ghana – West African use of wild and cultivated plants.
Intermediate Technology Publications and the Royal Botanic Gardens Kew. Richmond,United
Kingdom. pp. 337
2. Abdel-Galil F.M., El-Jissry M.A. (1990) Cyclopeptide alkaloids from Zizyphus spina-christi.
Phytochemistry v. 30 (4): p. 1348-1349.
3. Adzu B., Amos S., Amizan M.B., Gamaniel K., (2003) Evaluation of the antidiarrhoeal effects of
Zizyphus spina-christi stem bark in rats. Acta Trop. 87(2): 245-50.
4. Adzu B., Amos S., Wambebe C., Gamaniel K., (2001) Antinociceptive activity of Zizyphus
spina-christi root bark extract. Fitoterapia. 72(4): 344.
5. Amin G. (1991) Popular Medicinal Plants of Iran. Vol.1. Ministry of Health Publications, Tehran. p
67.
6. Anand K.K., Singh B., Chand D., Chandan B.K., Gupta V. (1989) Effect of Zizyphus sativa leaves
on blood glucose levels in normal and alloxan-diabetic rats. J Ethnopharmacol, 27:121-125.
7. Aynehchi Y., Mahoodian M. (1973) Chemical examination of Zizyphus spina-christi (L.) Willd.
Acta Pharm Suec,Dec;10(6):515-9.
8. Benammar C., Hichami A., Yessoufou A., Simonin A.., Belarbi M., Allali H. Naim A Khan. (2010)
Zizyphus lotus L. (Desf.) modulates antioxidant activity and human T-cell proliferation BMC
Complementary and Alternative Medicine, 10:54.
9. Borgi W., Bouraoui A., Chouchane N. (2007) Antiulcerogenic activity of Zizyphus lotus (L.)
extracts. J Ethnopharmacol, 112:228-231.
10. Borgi W., Recio M.C., Ríos J.L., Chouchane N. (2008) Anti-inflammatory and analgesic activities
of flavonoid and saponin fractions from Zizyphus lotus (L) Lam. South Afr J Bot, 74:320-324.
11. Borgi, W. and Chouchane, N. I(2009) Anti-inflammatory and analgesic activities of flavonoid and
saponin fractions from Zizyphus lotus (L.) Lam. S. Afr. J. Bot. 74:320–324.
Archives Des Sciences Vol 66, No. 5;May 2013
697 ISSN 1661-464X
12. Bouaziz M., Dhouib A., Loukil S., Boukhris M. and Sayadi S. (2009) Polyphenols content,
antioxidant and antimicrobial activities of extracts of some wild plants collected from the south of
Tunisia. African Journal of Biotechnology Vol. 8 (24), pp. 7017-7027, 15.
13. Campbell KJ, Kirkwood AR (1993) Effects of topical oils on TEWL in dogs with seborrhea sicca. In
: Adv. Vet. Derm. II, Eds Ihrke PJ, Mason IS, White SD, Pergamon Press, Oxford, 157-162.
14. Cassidy A. (2003) Potential risks and benefits of phytoestrogen-rich diets. Int J Vitam Nutr
Res.,73:120–126.
15. Curtis C.F. (1998) Use and abuse of topical dermatological therapy in dogs and cats. Part 1-
shampoo therapy. In Practice, 244-251.
16. Dafni, A., Levy S. And Lev E. (2005). The ethnobotany of Christ's Thorn Jujube (Ziziphus
spina-christi) in Israel. Journal of Ethnobiology and Ethnomedicine 1 (8): 1-8.
17. Farooqi A. (1997) Plants of the Qur'an. Lucknow (India): Sidrah Publishers; 65-74.
18. Hewitt P.G , Hotchkiss S.A.M. and Perkins J. (2000) Metabolism of fluroxypyr, fluroxypyr
methylester and fluroxypyr methylheptyl ester. I: During percutaneous absorption through fresh
ratand human skin in vitro. Drug Metab Dispos28:748 –754.
19. Hwang K.H., Han Y.N., Han B.H., (2001) Inhibition of calmodulin-dependent calcium-ATPase and
phosphodiesterase by various cyclopeptides and peptide alkaloids from the Zizyphus species. Arch
Pharm Res. 24(3): 202-6.
20. Ikram M., Tomlinson H. (1976) Chemical constituents of Zizyphus spina christi. Planta Med
May;29(3):289-90.
21. Kokate C.K., Purohit A.P., Gokhale S.B. (2003) Pharmacognosy. 24th ed. Pune: Nirali
Prakakashan; p.149-153.
22. Lahlou M., El Mahi M., Hamamouchi J., ( 2002) Evaluation of antifungal and 5.mollusuicidial
activities of Moroccan Zizyphus lotus (L.) Desf Ann Pharm Fr. 60(6): 410-4.
Archives Des Sciences Vol 66, No. 5;May 2013
698 ISSN 1661-464X
23. Le Floc’h, E. (1983) Contribution a une etude ethnobotanique de la flore de la Tunisie. Imprimerie
officielle de la Republique Tunisienne, Tunis. . Programme Flore et Végétation tunisienne. Min. de
l’En. Sup. et de la Rech. Sci. 387 p.
24. Mahran, G.E.D.H., Glombitza K.W., Mirhom Y.W., Hartmann R., Michel C.G. (1996) Novel
saponins from Zizyphus spina-christi growing in Egypt. Planta Medica 62(2): 163-165.
25. Nafisy A.T. (1989) A Review of Traditional Medicine in Iran. Isfahan University Publications,
Isfahan. p 133.
26. Verma P.D. , Dangar R.D., Shah K.N., Gandhiand D.M., Suhagia B.N. (2011) Pharmacognostical
Potential of Capparis deciduas Edgew Journal of Applied Pharmaceutical Science 01 (10); 06-11.
27. Pandey V.B., Devi S. (1990) Biologically active cyclopeptide alkaloids from rhamnaceae plants.
Planta Med; 56:649-650.
28. Patel R. G., Pathak N. L., Rathod J. D., Pateland B. N. (2011) Phytopharmacological Properties of
Randia dumetorumas a Potential Medicinal Tree: An Overview. Journal of Applied Pharmaceutical
Science 01 (10); 24-26.
29. Pottier Alapetite G. ; 1979 : Flore de la Tunisie. Angiospermes- Dicotylédones, Apétales -
Dialypétales. Programme flore et vegetation tunisiennes. 651p.
30. Rona C., Vailati F., Berardesca E. (2004) The cosmetic treatment of wrinkles. J Cosmet
Dermatol.;3:26–34.
31. Shahat A.A., Pieters L., Apers S., Nazeif N.M., Abdel-Azim N.S., Berghe D.V., Vlietinck A.J.
(2001) Chemical and biological investigations on Zizyphus spina-christi L. Phytother Res. 15(7):
593-7.
32. Tschesche R. and Kaubmann E.U. (1975) The Alkaloids. Volume XV. Edited by Manske R. HF
AdemicPress, New York; 165-205
33. Younes M.E., Amer M.S., El-Messallami A.D.E. (1996) Phytochemical examination of the leaves
of the Egyptian Zizyphus spina christi “Nabc”. Bulletin of the National Research Centre (Cairo)
21(1): 35-40.
Archives Des Sciences Vol 66, No. 5;May 2013